Many patients with common variable immunodeficiency (CVID), including those with CTLA4 deficiency, NFKB1 variants and activated PI3K-delta syndrome (APDS), develop autoimmunity that is refractory to treatment. Despite this shared clinical phenotype, a unifying mechanism for the breakdown of B cell tolerance across monogenic forms of CVID has not been established. Here, we demonstrate that patients with loss-of-function NFKB1 variants, like those with CTLA4 variants and APDS, exhibit dysregulated CD4 + T cell expansion, accumulation of transitional B cells, and a relative lack of follicular B cells. In patients with monogenic CVID and clinical autoimmunity, we observed a relative expansion of transitional and activated naïve (aN: CD21 lo CD11c hi ) B cells in peripheral blood accompanied by a marked increase in the frequency of VH4-34 expressing autoreactive 9G4 + B cells, which expanded between T2 and T3a transitional B cell stages. Single-cell transcriptomic and B cell receptor analysis further revealed a marked expansion of activated T1/2, T3 and extrafollicular activated naïve and double negative (DN: IgD - CD27 - ) B cell subsets in APDS patients. Notably, one B cell subset appeared exclusively in the APDS disease state, characterized by high oxidative phosphorylation in transitional B cells, specifically. In APDS patients, we also observed a clonal expansion of specific extrafollicular class-switched DN B cells, which were clonally derived from activated transitional B cells. DN B cells were also identified in APDS lung tissue, consistent with the contribution of activated, extrafollicularly-derived B cells to tissue inflammation. Together, these findings suggest that in many patients with CVID and autoimmune features, premature activation of autoreactive transitional T2 and T3a B cells induces the survival and expansion, rather than the tolerization and elimination, of self-reactive B cells. This process leads to extrafollicular expansion of autoreactive B cells capable of tissue infiltration. Loss of transitional B cell tolerance and extrafollicular expansion of autoreactive B cells drive autoimmunity in monogenic causes of CVID.

Reduced function or hypomorphic variants in recombination-activating genes (RAG) 1 or 2 result in a broad clinical phenotype including common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) and even adult-onset disease. Milder RAG variants are less characterized. Here we describe the longitudinal course of a milder combined RAG deficiency in 3 of 7 siblings sharing the same RAG2 mutations over a 50-year study. Whole-genome and repertoire sequencing, bacteriophage immunizations, and deep immunophenotyping were used to compare affected and unaffected family members. The clinical phenotype of three affected siblings with hypomorphic RAG deficiency ranged from combined immunodeficiency and early mortality to a late-onset CID with hyper-IgM phenotype. T cells were remarkably similar across affected siblings, yet CDR3 skewing and regulatory T cell defects were not observed. B cell analysis showed elevated unswitched CD27+ and CD21low cells as well as features of an autoreactive antibody repertoire and presence of secreted autoantibodies, yet no clinical autoimmunity was present. Most striking was an expanded polyclonal marginal zone-like B cell population (IgM+IgD+CD27+) utilizing the self-reactive unmutated VH4-34 receptor demonstrating that hypomorphic RAG deficiency can promote expansion of self-reactive B cells. This process, however, was not sufficient to trigger clinical autoimmunity. Utilizing multiple approaches, we functionally measured the specific RAG2 variant effects and assessed how selection and secondary triggers altered the BCR repertoire and immunophenotype overtime. Overall, we demonstrate a broad disease spectrum in siblings with identical hypomorphic RAG deficiency, highlighting that phenotypic divergence can result from expansion of IgM + memory B cells.

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is an inborn error of immunity characterized by low levels of antibodies. In addition to infections, many patients also suffer from T-helper 1-driven immune dysregulation, which is associated with increased mortality. The aim of this study was to perform in-depth characterization of the T and the B cell compartments in a well-defined cohort of patients affected by CVID and correlate the findings to the level of clinical immune dysregulation. We used mass cytometry, targeted proteomics, flow cytometry and functional assays to delineate the immunological phenotype of 15 CVID-affected patients with different levels of immune dysregulation. Unbiased clustering of T cell mass cytometry data correlated with CVID-related immune dysregulation and plasma protein profiles. Expanded CXCR3+ T-bet-expressing B cells correlated with effector memory CD4+ T cell clusters, and increased plasma levels of CXCR3-ligands. Our findings indicate an interplay between B cells and T cells in CVID-related immune dysregulation and provide a better understanding of the underlying pathological mechanisms.

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is established as a heterogeneous collection of disorders of immune dysregulation rather than an infectious complication of antibody deficiency. Approximately 70% of patients have one or more of the non-infectious complications of autoimmunity, enteropathy, polyclonal lymphocytic and malignancy. The CVID-disorders represent a particular challenge as they fall under an umbrella diagnosis governed currently by non-universal diagnostic criteria. The rubric of CVID is shrinking as next generation sequencing is progressively and rapidly identifying the genetic basis for many of its disorders. Although identification of monogenic cause of CVID allows for naming of separate or specific entities, it still provides valuable insight into the immune dysregulation of these disorders along with recognition of a polygenic basis of disease and cellular changes observed in innate and adaptive immune pathways. Cellular abnormalities in the T-cell (reduced regulatory T cells (Tregs) and increased T follicular helper cells), and B-cell compartments (reduced switched memory B-cells and increased peripheral CD21low cells) along with an increase in innate lymphoid cells type 3 promote a milieu for inflammation. Immune dysregulation also results from increased microbial translocation from impaired gastrointestinal barrier function in CVID-patients with loss of Tregs. An understanding of the manifestations and mechanisms of immune dysregulation allows for improved vigilance in screening for the diagnosis, monitoring for complications of disease and the continued development and introduction of targeted therapies for non-infectious phenotypes.

We report on an observational, multicenter study of 345 adult CVID patients, designed to assess the diagnostic value and the clinical association of serum free light chain (sFLC) pattern in Common Variable Immunodeficiency disorders (CVID). Sixty CVID patients were tested twice in order to assess intraindividual variability of sFLC. As control groups we included 138 patients affected by undefined primary antibody defects (UAD), lymphoproliferative diseases (LPDs), and secondary antibody deficiencies not related to hematological malignancies (SID). CVID patients presented lower κ and λ chain concentration compared to controls, showing low intraindividual sFLC variability. On the basis of the sFLC pattern, patients were classified into four groups: κ-λ+, κ+λ-, κ-λ-, κ+λ+. The most common pattern in CVID patients was κ-λ- (51%), followed by κ-λ+, (25%), κ+λ+ (22%), and κ+λ- (3%). In UAD, LPD, and SID groups κ+λ+ was the most common pattern observed. By analyzing the possible association between sFLC patterns and disease-related complications of CVID, we observed that patients belonging to the κ-λ- group presented more commonly unexplained enteropathy compared to the κ+λ+ group and showed higher frequency of bronchiectasis and splenomegaly compared to both the κ-λ+ and κ+λ+ patients. When compared to the other groups, κ-λ- had also lower serum IgG, IgA, and IgM concentrations at diagnosis, lower frequency of CD27+IgD-IgM- switched memory B cells, and higher frequency of CD21low B cells, receiving earlier CVID diagnosis. Thus, lower levels of sFLC might be an epiphenomenon of impairment in B cell differentiation, possibly leading κ-λ- patients to a higher risk for bacterial infections and chronic lung damage. Based on these results, we suggest adding sFLC assay to the diagnostic work-up of hypogammaglobulinemia and during follow-up. The assay may be useful to differentiate CVID from other causes of hypogammaglobulinemia and to early detect monoclonal lymphoproliferation occurring over years. Moreover, since the sFLC pattern seems to be related to disease phenotypes and clinical manifestations of CVID and after confirmation by further studies, sFLC assay might be considered a promising prognostic tool for identifying patients at higher risk of developing enteropathy and chronic lung damage or splenomegaly. This will allow designing a tailored follow-up for CVID patients.